Many compounds hold promise for pharmacologic manipulation of aging. However, such claims are difficult to investigate due to time and budget constraints. Here, we took a comparative approach, using short-lived invertebrate species, to directly test the effects of two tocopherols (Vitamin E) on longevity. gamma-Tocopherol represents the most abundant tocopherol in the Western diet, while alpha-tocopherol is selectively enriched in human plasma. Both isoforms demonstrate antioxidant activity and are proposed to have anti-aging activities. We compared the effects of alpha- and gamma-tocopherol supplementation on lifespan in three invertebrate species. gamma-Tocopherol, but not alpha-tocopherol, slightly extended lifespan in nematodes, but neither significantly affected lifespan in two fly species. This study shows that a comparative approach, utilizing multiple invertebrate species, can increase the robustness of invertebrate-based pilot screens for prolongevity interventions.