Text file: 6411.txt
author: studenecuros
downvotes: 8
end consideration date: 2015-01-13
id: '6411'
number comments: 2
number views: 1760
proposal type: Competent authority response
response: "Response from the Ministry of Infrastructure\nThere have been a number\
  \ of similar proposals in the past. Recordings of the driving test would be very\
  \ useful for educational purposes, but not for determining the behaviour of the\
  \ candidate and the other members of the driving test committee and the driving\
  \ instructor accompanying the candidate during the practical part of the driving\
  \ test, and would only make sense in a way where what is happening inside the vehicle\
  \ and what is happening outside the vehicle (i.e. the traffic situation encountered\
  \ by the candidate during the driving test) could be monitored simultaneously. For\
  \ this purpose, at least two cameras should be installed, synchronously showing\
  \ what is happening inside the vehicle and its surroundings, and installed according\
  \ to uniform standards.\nThe Information Commissioner also considers that (from\
  \ the point of view of the protection of personal data) the recording of events\
  \ inside and outside the vehicle, for the purpose of objectively determining the\
  \ candidate's behaviour in relation to the traffic situation, is only permissible\
  \ with the consent of all the identified or identifiable individuals in the recording.\
  \ In the case of recording events inside the vehicle, this would be feasible (obtaining\
  \ the consent of all individuals in the recording is possible), but in the case\
  \ of recording events outside the vehicle, it is not feasible (obtaining the consent\
  \ of all individuals in the recording is impracticable). However, in the opinion\
  \ of the Information Commissioner, the recording of individuals without their consent\
  \ could constitute a legal basis for the criminal or civil liability of the author\
  \ of the recording.\n \n "
response date: 2015-02-10
response due date: null
sent date: 2014-12-15
title: Recording the test drive
upvotes: 15
url: https://predlagam.vladi.si/predlog/6411
